people are paying 100 dollars for gma 10 kobe rc reprints. (At least theyre being honest. Its been manipulated; so, so bad.. Duly noted. This shattered the record for a trading card sale by an extensive margin. I think they need more research and input. 0 Likes, Added by Steve Cyrkin, Admin So the pecking order looks like this: Question regarding Beckett, PSA, JSA autograph authentication as much as it should have. I looked at one example: 1991 Michael Jordan Upper Deck #SP1 (baseball, not basketball). Beckett's New Autograph Authentication Stickers Offer Hologram, QR Code These are my preferred choices because I care about the market value of my cards and want to be able to capture the highest prices from buyers. I guess thats why people are still using it. never seen prices like this before. Signature Review generally takes 24-48 hours. Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator. When the Referred customer account has been activated with the purchased subscription(s), the Referrer will receive a referral reward which is 10% of the total amount spent by the Referred customer for purchasing the OPG subscription(s). I was under the impression that Beckett was one of the better ones out there. Just because theyve been around longer doesnt make them better. While edging is often seen as the least important factor, it still has a significant impact on the overall rating. It could be a strong up and comer, but time will tell. Why Pay More? 20-50 items = $12.00 each. Both the company and the grade determine the market value of a card. All rights reserved. Not only are they cheaper ($30 to $100 at the base pricing level for one single card) but more and more collectors believe that SGC (Sports Guaranty Company) is, ar best, actually a superior grader to PSA, and on equal footing at worst. And the 1964 Barratt is the only rookie issue that has ever been produced. These may be lousy on-the-fly ones. Im surprised not many of you have heard about this, I thought this was bigger back then when people found out. PSA used to exclusively grade using whole numbers but changed to allow for half grades in February 2008. (In fact, the Beckett Grading Scale and SGC Grading Scale are the most similar of the trio). Infact Beckett is one of top 3 autograph verification companies, even i think is one of the very top companies for autograph verification. Report an Issue | When Steve Grad left PSA for Beckett they gained a lot of creditability. Global Authentication Inc? - Beckett Media But at least looking at Topps/Bowman baseball cards from 50s & 60s, a graded card goes for about three to four times the cost of an ungraded card in the same condition. I have to weigh in here from a perspective that I dont think I saw in any of the comments. On the card, they didnt even list all of the Hall of Fame autographs on it. Introducing, Beckett Authentication Signature Review Service. Federal law enforcement officials have launched a criminal investigation encompassing one of baseball card collecting's largest authentication firms, a well-known sports memorabilia dealer and. csg pretty much copied bgs , they have 2 different 10s. Ive been told their print run was 2000, but I have no way to verify that.. Founded in 1998 and headquartered in Boca Raton, FL, SGC is a well-established grading company with history. He continued: back in 1910, 1911, they didnt have an excellent process for manufacturing and cutting the cards, so many of them were not uniformly cut. gma grades are more accurate than bccg but bccg is still worth more than gma. Is GAA Authenticated Autographs a trustworthy COA company? It looks like recent sales on this card were the following: PSA 10 ($730), BGS 9.5 ($300), SGC 9.5 ($188), CGS 9.5 ($190). The web's home of guaranteed authentic original autographs. Im actully about to send to Mint. I think (hope) that as the prices continue to outrageously skyrocket (as grading companies continue to raise their prices, this will also artificially raise the value of the graded cards), that many others who are simply collecting and not trying to get rich, will see it that way too, and the bubble will start to burst. Trading card prices are in a boom town right now, but anyone who remembers the junk wax era will tell you- dont always believe the hype. In fact, I just sent them some cards. Posted by Tim G. on October 1, 2018 at 5:20pm in Town Square. Ross described it as probably even more expensive now due to its infamy, rather than the actual card itself.. I was just asking because Steve Grad, the primary administrator of Beckett was caught up in a bunch of scandals and lies involving wrongfully authenticating autographs, and lying about his experience as a trained authenticator. One other thing thats worth mentioning in the hierarchy of grades: Beckett has two different versions of a 10 and so does SGC. A unique Beckett Grading Services feature comes in the form of a Report Card which provides specific grade details and leaves no confusion as to why your card received its grade. 2 Comments As the buyer you may be uncertain if the item is genuinely authentic, and don't want to risk hundreds of dollars by purchasing the item without it being reviewed by expert authenticators. As for the grading system, its similar to the PSA scale in terms of descriptors and numbers, but they have several extra grades for each of the half-points. And totally agree with you on PSA pricing model. To be eligible for participation in the Program, the Referrer must be a registered member of Beckett. And he showed me the guy, and this guy had two stacks of PSA graded Gretzky O-Pee-Chee rookies, they were all counterfeit. This is the process that I followed and the lessons learned. Phone: 1-800-325-1121 or if outside the United States call (949) 833-8824, Mail: PSA, P.O. With tech-enabled services and a new pricing model, they seem to be disrupting card grading in a good way. Copyright 2022-2023 beckett-authentication.com. Your analysis is interesting but flawed. We purchase sports cards as an alternative investment to stocks, bonds, and real estate. One of the most effective ways to spot a fake slab is to take a closer look at the label. Just like it was all about the guarantee on the box for Ted. Beckett reserves the right, at its sole discretion, to prohibit any Member from participating in any aspect of the Program if Beckett deems or suspects that such Member has engaged in or has attempted to engage in any of the following: Beckett shall be the sole determiner in cases of suspected abuse, fraud, or breach of these Program Terms and Conditions or intent of these Program Terms and Conditions. Yes, if it's real it can be trusted pretty well. Putting something of mine thats rare and valuable in the mail just so a stranger can judge it, assign it a number, and permanently seal it in a plastic holder doesnt appeal to me. Some people without a ton of money and/or the ability to wait for large stretches of time will likely find HGA appealing. For a cost of $10, a Beckett authenticator will review the item and offer their opinion on whether the item would likely pass the full authentication process. 0 Likes, by Greg Jeranek So a buyer assumes that PSA, SGC, Beckett goes through a rigorous process to ensure that its not trimmed or altered; and after that, what sort of condition is it in? And thats when they grabbed a stranglehold because guys were making money off of them. My first foray into the hobby came just a few years before the junk wax era took hold, and back then Beckett was THE BIBLE. Ross explained other instances and practices. Organize and price your collections as we offer instant access to the world's leading trading card and collectibles databases, including baseball cards, basketball cards, football cards, non-sports cards, gaming cards and more. Lastly, I would say it really depends on what youre looking to do with the card. The Beckett Black Label commands extremely high prices in the trading card market. Report an Issue | But the story of this specific issue was just getting started- its the most notorious incident of card trimming that the world has ever seen. And so thats why they do it. The biggest reason to me is that it is illogical that a third party grade raises the value of the card. Beckett may, in its sole and absolute discretion, terminate or suspend any Members participation in the Program for breach of these Program Terms and Conditions or taking any actions that are inconsistent with the intent of these Program Terms and Conditions. Powered by, Badges | I will make sure to keep that in mind for next time. Beckett is among the leading publisher of sports and entertainment market collectibles. Thank you. 0 Comments My top picks for card grading companies in 2021 are PSA, BGS, and SGC. With CSG and HGA, the collector has to ask himself- will they be around in 10 years? I said this is the deal. Sure, I may be leaving a lot of money on the table. Autograph Live: It's easy to add a musician-direct sales notice as a discussion. The Beckett grading in-person option was available at an event I attended the line was long but went quick. But I said, Im not trying to complain, but I did pay cash for this. And thats one of many reasons why you pay to have your card evaluated for things like that. But if you're skeptical of Beckett, try another authenticator. That said, they have not been able to leverage that yesteryear hegemony into dominating the grading marketplace today. Not a whole lot has been said and written about them, but Ross agrees with me in that they seem to do an alright job from what we have seen and heard. A Qualified Referral occurs when: i. LEGIT ?? Because the person who grades it can sell it for three to four times as much money. When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Theyre cheaper and turn-times are quicker. Heres how I see it. Anyone have any solutions or ideas? And I like that a 10 is a 10. Shyne refunded Logan already. Just look at the Lucky 7s T206 owner. Thats one theory about how and why PSA got to where they are today. Beckett 10 Sure, a fair amount of training is involved, but could it really be that difficult? He used to be good with a lot of signatures. COA and trusted companies? Collectors Universe Garnett was at a large card show in Pasadena, California in 1980. 1: This card usually exhibits many of these characteristics: heavy print spots, heavy crease(s), pinhole(s), color or focus imperfections or discoloration, surface scuffing or tears, rounded and/or fraying corners, ink or pencil marking(s), and lack of all or some original gloss, small portions of the card may be missing. People use PSA because its a trusted source with the highest return on investment., I prefer BGS due to subgrades. Is CSG good? You need to factor in the cost of grading the card to the analysis. Thanks! YOU PAY ME, I'LL AUTHENTICATE IT, SAYS BECKETT. Other than that I havent had any other problems with either of the two., PSA cards grade higher than BGS which we like BUT they take FOREVER (especially if the card is a patch/autograph. It looks like recent sales on this card were the following: PSA 10 ($730), BGS 9.5 ($300), SGC 9.5 ($188), CGS 9.5 ($190). Staining (ST) Staining will also diminish value, and its more prevalent with vintage cards. Rank the COA companies - Blowout Cards Forums This is a $5,000 card that were talking about, and even when the stakes are high like this, graders can get things wrong. According to the HGA website, the company states, HGA is revolutionizing the industry by implementing software that will allow [them] to scan, analyze, and grade cards without subjectivity.. We recommend cutting two pieces of cardboard around the card and wrapping the final coating in bubble wrap. Wasnt it proven that the primary administrator, Steve Grad was a fraud and got in some authenticating scandals. Potentially, they could be losing market share enough that they may even cut prices down the road. Reward Conditions. I was big on BGS, but the more Ive gotten back into the hobby, I prefer PSA. However, the excessive demand to get PSA grades has led to prohibitive pricing and prolonged turnaround time. 0 Likes, 2023 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin. Which grading service is best for you, and why? Your email address will not be published. But really its not. Sorry, no on-site encapsulation is available WHAT CAN BE AUTHENTICATED: So why do you let them get away with taking YOUR potential profit or value? Btw im in the US and its still cheaper to send 2 cards there and get them back in 6 days than it is to send them to CGC for about 90 days. The full amount, with Sothebys fees included, was $451,000 (which is $892,360 today, when adjusted for inflation). For that, we take you back to the 1994 Chris Farley and David Spade film Tommy Boy. There is a scene where Tommy (Farley) encounters an auto parts mega store manager named Ted, who is obsessed with guarantees being prominently present on all product boxes. In 2019, the largest seller of cards on eBay, PWCC,was caught up in a trimming scandal, having sold millions of dollars worth of cards that were allegedly altered fraudulently. His reason is simple, there is no official guarantee displayed on the product, as he tells him: Its not there on the box, comforting you, telling you Ill never go bad, and even if I do, Ill fix it and make it allllllllll better!. Thats a good question, responded Garnett. By participating in the Program, Participants release Beckett, its parent company, subsidiaries, affiliates, suppliers, advertising, and promotions agencies, and their respective directors, officers, employees, and agents from any and all liability for any loss, harm, damages, cost, or expense, including, without limitation, property damages, personal injury and/or death, arising out of or in any way connected to the Program and/or the use of any Program rewards. SGC/Beckett 9(SGC holds more weight in vintage, BGS out performs them in modern). There is no guarantee on the grade a card will receive, but a Gem-Mint or Pristine card will significantly increase the value of a trading card leading to card collectors and investors to submit thousands, if not millions, of cards each year for grading. Not the cheapest or quickest turnaround times. Because like all other grading companies there, and even the whole hobby knows, anybody who is in it with even a lick of sense knows this- they were over-grading a couple of years ago.. I like they are a trusted name once someone like me wants to resale. Just wondering how you feel about CSG? This theory certainly makes a lot of sense, as youre kind of a guinea pig on this. infact ebay lists Beckett as top 5 companies for autograph authentication services. Dr. James Beckett is The Godfather of the modern hobby, but what is he a Doctor of? I collected these cards based on condition. i wiffed the first swing (god da##it! The best company for authentication. At this price point, it doesn't cost much more than a one touch case to get your cards graded. I like the eye appeal over the other companies. White borders can blend more quickly, making it slightly more challenging to detect any flaws. But its gotten so expensive to grade cards that its really getting out of hand. That is the most important part. These Program Terms and Conditions are a binding agreement between you and Beckett and will govern your participation in any and all Program offers. Is it a one, instead of two, is it a three, is it an eight?. Beckett Signature Review will allow customers to share a link or photo of an autograph that hasn't been authenticated by the company. The autograph experts at Beckett have vast experience with autographs from various genres and eras and have authenticated rare and valuable items. HGAs pricing based on turnaround time and not the card value is also attractive. Theyve always been a viable alternative since Ive re-entered collecting, said Ross. Card grading services seem like they are there more for the kind of people who either dont trust themselves enough to make big decisions for themselves, or, a safeguard for the hobby to ensure its relevance for years to come by providing the scarcity needed to drive/maintain a market that tends to crash itself from time to time due to over production. I mean the card itself in the set is not short-printed, but I just dont think the English made much of that stuff. He no longer has the issue today, but its a 1964 BarrattGeorge Best rookie card. PSA currently offers a similar "Quick Opinion" service for items being offered by eBay sellers. Indemnification. Simply put, they dominated pricing back then in the same way that PSA dominates grading now. Maybe others have a difference of opinion. I got a tom brady graded it got a 10, 9.5,9, 7.5 overall it got an 8. like bgs they only go up a half point to a point from the lowest sub grade . We use Beckett on the majority of our cards we get graded. The transition from boom to bust might not be too far off. Here are the contact details for each of the services. Its nerdy, super nerdy, Ross continued. For example, the 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan RC#57 SGC 10 sold for ~$150,000 in January 2021. Please keep in mind, while our staff does its best to process each request in a timely manner, there may be instances where requests are made too close to the end of an auction. Lets say you receive an SGC 10 2020 Justin Herbert Prizm RC and a PSA 10 of the same card). With a focus on integrity, commitment, and accuracy, Beckett will continue to be a leader in the collectibles industry providing dynamic . Its PSA authenticated but my problem with it is they rushed the authentication. Beckett Does 3rd Party Autograph Authentication - Who is the Best? PSA was the first major grading company, as they got the ball rolling in 1991. Given the prices and rarity of some cards today, well, lets just say the classic principals of supply and demand must be taken into account. Sometimes I use PSA; sometimes I use BGS, sometimes I use SGC, it just depends on the card, I have a signed baseball with the likes of Mickey Cochrane, Rogers Hornsby, Bill McGowan, dizzy dean, and others. I like they are a trusted name once someone like me wants to resale. Its perfect to be the King, and to set prices, so PSA remains in pole position. Doesnt seem to be that way anymore. Copyright 2022-2023 beckett-authentication.com. I dont know. Ok. its not like topps is reprinting, its probably illegal . So with all due respect to all the grading companies out there, on the consumer end, its just all about the name on the slab. You are not authorized to participate in the Program if you do not agree to these Program Terms and Conditions in their entirety. A. Some companies like PSA, BAS, JSA are trustworthy while others are known to pass everything. Is there anyone better placed to give their opinions about the three services than our readers? Bidding rose swiftly, from an opening bid of $114,000 to the hammer price of $410,000. I was looking at purchasing a personalized autograph poster of Rocky Horror Picture Show from GalaxyCon. 50/50 centering, crisp focus, four sharp corners*, free of stains, no breaks in surface gloss, no print or refractor lines, and no visible wear under magnification. Thats certainly true in the hobby today. In other words, poor centering will drag the overall rating down, even if the card is perfect in every other way. I got spare time. I think its nothing short of amazing. really depends on that card that you want to get graded Just write to us what you need. For example, the company states, Customers are always pleased when their grading experiences feature quick turnaround, consistent grading, and a quality productall at a fair price. People use PSA because its a trusted source with the highest return on investment. Joe K. Norwalk, IA, I prefer BGS due to subgrades. If that is not a concern of yours, I think the quality of grading you would get from CSG would be just fine. All legitimate worries. Is Beckett authentication still legit? - Autograph Live Centering The centering considers how the image fits the card, and how it aligns with the border. Beckett Media | Better Business Bureau Profile Tweet Ive sent many cards using a combination of penny sleeves, semi-rigid card holders, painters tape, cardboard box pieces, and packing paper and have never had an issue with cards getting damaged. The benefits of doing this are obvious. A gold/black label on the front of the cardholder signifies the highest graded cards (9.5-10), while a silver label can be found on cards graded from 8.5 to 9. GMA offers lower-priced grading services because they do not have the same brand recognition as PSA and BGS. So, you would rank an autograph authenticated/witnessed by them up there with MLB, in terms of credibility ? Sports and Non-Sports Cards.. Regardless of which you choose, all six card grading companies exist to support your enjoyment of the card collecting hobby. I used the following parameters: Although it is important to keep in mind this analysis is for only one card, there are several interesting takeaways from this analysis: Fortunately, there are only a few items you may need before you submit your cards for grading, including: The most important part is ensuring that your cards are protected during shipping. A person who is not a party to these Program Terms and Conditions shall have no right to enforce or receive the benefit of any of these Program Terms and Conditions. Add. The same is true if portions of more than one card are visible. But why do they put a guarantee on the box then? Pretty cool option Beckett should look into having this option at local card shows in major cities. Mike S. Kansas City, MO, I would rate Beckett grading services a solid 9 out of 10. 2018-19 Panini Prizm #45 Allen Iverson - Check out your favorite player cards listed in Beckett Marketplace. This business is not an Accredited Business of this BBB and our policies prohibit such a reference. Facebook. Grading card companies started in early 1990s and since then have become a mainstay in the trading card industry. I also see as many JSA or PSA certified autographs as Beckett.I used Beckett once, a big plus for me what Beckett has in contrast to the others, you can fill out the submission online.It was perfect for me. 0 Comments Just depends on the cards that we are getting graded., I prefer to use PSA. PSA Authentication and Grading Services, the industrys leading card grading organization (as weve said over and over again), called it the most recognizable basketball card and the most important modern card from any sport in the entire hobby. Finding a truly mint condition, top-tier, flawless card is tough. Step 4: Documentation. PSA and Beckett can face issues if they continue to either not take submissions and/or have lengthy delays in service. So the only question remains, can SGC step up and replace PSA as the guarantee that people most covet? Ive never been a fan of having cards graded. It seems to be a common perception, some might even say an unwritten rule, that you never want to be the first person to ever get a specific card graded. Tier 4 - Buyer Beware: These are the items/authentication that may have, at one point, been legit, maybe even reputable, but are very prone to fakes due to their methods of authentication OR the companies themselves went/were crooked. PSA wait times will be the longest of the BIG three on average. Founded in 2010 and headquartered in New Hudson, MI, International Sports Authentication (ISA) is an up-and-coming grading service in the card grading industry. The section titles in these Program Terms and Conditions are for convenience only and have no legal or contractual effect. Pwcc will allow us to sell bccg cards on their marketplace but they wont allow gma cards. I feel more comfortable making the purchase now. Yes they are legit and infact they will let you pay $10 for a quick opinion if you wanted for your questionable autographed items. 0 Comments When i see a signatures in felt pen, i have fear to buy Steve Grad is the ultimate Metallica fan and extremely good on their autographs. Does anyone have advice for me on how to start the process of grading them, which cards to submit, to where and most cost effective way to do so? No. Research into Becketts Black Box algorithm. Trimming is the practice of slightly cutting a card so that one can minimally alter the width and or height. Maybe it says something about PSA being too high-priced for many collectors? And that is fine, because right now, there are people who will pay for thatI just cant see why. Cheap Pricing - GMA is by far the cheapest semi-reputable grading company out there right now. With this specific niche, its all about the brand, and that makes sense because a brand, by business school textbook definition, is how that product/service evokes thoughts, feelings and emotions. Do I receive a Certificate/Letter of Authenticity if my item is found Likely Genuine? I wouldnt want to be holding a million dollars worth of branded cards, Ill just leave it at that. No Discount For Items Listed Over $250. PSA 10 So we looked it up- turns out Beckett earned a Ph.D. degree in statistics at Southern Methodist University in 1975, and then joined the faculty of Bowling Green State University as an Associate Professor. There was a lot of riffraff in the hobby, as he tells it. I had no idea. Just a couple of days ago, the Federal Reserve hinted that its first rate hike since 2018 could be in the near future, saying it could happen soon. This announcement came amid the Central Banks elevated concerns that theyll need to be more aggressive in combating this persistent runaway inflation, and thats been a major catalyst to this months extreme volatility in the stock market. Summary: SGC Grading should be selected on the majority of your cards. We are the web's leading supplier of genuine signed photos and original autographs. Ivanka Trump Rare! Just look at the Lucky 7s T206 owner. The original post was asking about Global Authentication Inc, which does autograph authentication. And Gretzky and McNall bought it, and then through a federal investigation, they determined that it was altered and part of a fraud case. I should know that, but I dont. Only you can determine if it is worth it to have TTM autos authenticated. Participants in the Program must comply with all up to date SPAM laws. You pay for turnaround time, but not card value. In fact, a PSA/DNA Mint + 9.5 single-signed baseball sold for $3,107 in November of 2013. We strive to provide simple, straightforward advice that is objective, independent, and honest, helping you get the most for your money in the sports card investment world. Beckett reserves the right to cancel or suspend the Program should it determine, in its sole discretion, that the administration, security, or fairness of the Program has been compromised in any way.